Written by: Garbis Kolokossian
If you’ve been harmed by someone’s actions, you might be wondering who can be held responsible. In some cases, it’s not just the individual who caused the harm that can be held liable – their employer or another related party might also be responsible under a legal concept called ‘vicarious liability.’
This article aims to help you understand what vicarious liability is, how it might apply to your situation, and what you need to know if you’re considering making a personal injury claim.
What is vicarious liability?
Vicarious liability is a legal principle that holds one party responsible for the actions or omissions of another party. Typically, this applies in situations where there’s a special relationship between the two parties, such as:
- Employer and employee
- Principal and agent
- Partner and partnership
- Parent and child (in some circumstances).
Under vicarious liability, even if an employer or principal wasn’t directly involved in the wrongful act, they can still be held legally responsible for the actions of their employee or agent.
When does vicarious liability apply?
You might have a claim involving vicarious liability if:
- The person who caused the harm was employed by or acting as an agent for another party
- The harmful act occurred during the course of their employment or agency
- The act was somehow connected to the employee’s authorised duties.
It’s important to note that the exact requirements can vary depending on your jurisdiction and the specific circumstances of the case.
Examples of vicarious liability
To help you understand how vicarious liability might apply in real-life situations, let’s look at some examples.
| Employer-employee relationship | A delivery driver for a local pizza chain causes a car accident while making a delivery, injuring another motorist in a motor vehicle accident. The pizza company could be held vicariously liable for the driver’s negligence because the accident occurred while the driver was performing job-related duties. The company could be liable because:
|
| Church-clergy relationship | In a recent high-profile case in Sydney, a church (the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Saint Maron) was held vicariously liable for the actions of a priest who sexually abused a child (an institutional abuse claim). The court found that the church was responsible because:
|
| Hospital-doctor relationship | A surgeon makes a critical error during an operation, causing severe complications for the patient. The hospital could be held vicariously liable for the surgeon’s mistake as part of a medical negligence claim. The hospital may be liable because:
|
| School-teacher relationship | A teacher fails to properly supervise students during a field trip, resulting in a student getting injured. The school could be held vicariously liable for the teacher’s professional negligence. The school may be liable because:
|
| Security company-guard relationship | A security guard at a shopping mall uses excessive force while apprehending a suspected shoplifter, causing injury. The security company could be held vicariously liable for the guard’s actions, failing their duty of care. The security guard may be liable because:
|
Why is vicarious liability important for your injury claim?
Understanding vicarious liability is crucial because it can significantly impact your personal injury claim:
1. Increased compensation
By holding a company or organisation liable, you might have access to greater financial resources for compensation. In the aforementioned 2024 case against the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Saint Maron, the plaintiff was awarded the sum of $1,480,251.65 jointly and separately from the first and second defendants.
2. Broader responsibility
It encourages organisations to take responsibility for the actions of their employees or agents.
3. Improved safety measures
The threat of vicarious liability often motivates companies to implement better training and safety protocols.
4. Justice and accountability
It can provide a sense of justice, especially in cases where the individual wrongdoer may not have the means to compensate you adequately.
Contact us for confidential, free advice.
Challenges you might face in a vicarious liability claim
While vicarious liability can be a powerful legal tool, these claims can present unique challenges:
1. Proving the relationship
You’ll need to establish that a relevant relationship (like employer-employee) existed at the time of the incident.
2. Scope of employment
You’ll have to show that the harmful act occurred within the scope of the person’s employment or agency.
3. Independent contractor issues
If the person who caused harm was an independent contractor rather than an employee, it can be more difficult to establish vicarious liability.
4. Corporate structure complications
In some cases, complex corporate structures can make it challenging to determine which entity should be held vicariously liable.
5. Statutory limitations
Some jurisdictions have laws that limit vicarious liability in certain situations.
Variations by state in vicarious liability claims
In Australia, while the general principles of vicarious liability are similar across the country, there can be some variations in how they are applied.
New South Wales
- NSW courts have been relatively broad in their interpretation of vicarious liability, particularly in cases involving intentional wrongdoing by employees. They follow common law principles.
- The ‘close connection’ test is often applied, looking at whether the employee’s wrongful act was closely connected to their authorised duties.
Queensland
- Queensland follows similar principles to other states but has some specific statutory provisions relating to vicarious liability in its Civil Liability Act 2003.
- These provisions can affect how vicarious liability is applied in certain situations, such as against institutions for child abuse.
Australian Capital Territory
- The ACT follows common law principles of vicarious liability.
- Like other states, they consider the connection between the employee’s duties and the wrongful act.
Recent developments in vicarious liability law
The concept of vicarious liability has been evolving, with recent court decisions providing more clarity on its application. One significant case is the High Court of Australia’s decision in CCIG Investments Pty Ltd v Shokman [2023] HCA 21.
The Schokman case
The case, decided in August 2023, provides important insights into how courts interpret vicarious liability:
- The case involved an employee who was urinated on by his inebriated roommate (also an employee) in employer-provided accommodation.
- The High Court unanimously ruled that the employer was not vicariously liable for the roommate’s actions.
- The Court emphasises that while the incident occurred during employment, it was not sufficiently related to the employment to establish vicarious liability.
This decision highlights the complexity of determining when an employer can be held responsible for an employee’s actions. Especially when those actions occur outside of direct work duties.
Types of vicarious liability
In the same judgement, the justices set out that there are three different concepts that are often confused with vicarious liability.
These are:
- Vicarious acts: This involved acts authorised by the employer. It’s more accurately described as direct liability rather than vicarious liability.
- True vicarious liability: Liability attributed to the employer for unauthorised wrongful acts committed by an employee, provided they’re connected to the employee’s duties.
- Duty of Care: This occurs when an employer fails to properly delegate a duty of care to an employee or contractor.
Understanding what applies to your case is important to pursue a vicarious liability claim. Our team of lawyers can examine your case and best direct you.
Find out how much you can claim today.
How vicarious liability might affect your claim
If vicarious liability applies to your situation, it could affect your claim in a few ways:
- Your claim may have multiple defendants
- With a company potentially liable, there may be more resources available for increased compensation
- Dealing with a company’s legal team and insurers can make negotiations more complicated
- There may be a longer legal process given the complexities of the claim
- Your case might have a broader impact and lead to policy changes within the organisation, preventing similar incidents in the future.
How GMP Law can help
At GMP Law, we understand the complexities of vicarious liability claims and the impact they can have on your life.
We offer compassionate, personalised legal representation, guiding you through every step of the claims process. Our expertise in this nuanced area of law allows us to build strong cases, negotiate effectively with companies and their insurers, and advocate fiercely for your rights in court if necessary.
If you’ve been harmed due to someone’s actions while they were working or acting as an agent for another party, don’t face this challenging time alone. Contact us today for a free, no-obligation consultation.
Your rights matter, and we’re here to ensure they’re protected.
